Abstract
A global shift toward plant-based diets could significantly mitigate the negative impact of the food system on the environment, health, and animal welfare. While information provision has become a popular tool among policy-makers and social scientists to push consumers towards more sustainable diets, little is known about the population’s knowledge about the benefits of adopting a plant-based diet. Using data from a representative sample of the French population (N=715), we elicit the average knowledge about the relative merits of plant-based diets on the environment, health, and animal welfare. We show that people have on average a good knowledge of the relatively lower environmental impact of plant-based diets (GHG, land use) but considerably underestimate their health benefits. We also find that people significantly underestimate the prevalence of intensive farming and, therefore, the merits of adopting a plant-based diet for the animals. Our results show that society is predominantly divided into two groups: those who have a positive opinion of plant-based diets on all dimensions, and those who see less benefit in plant-based diets on all dimensions. We discuss the implications of these findings for the role of information campaigns in changing people’s diets.
Generated Summary
This study investigates the French population’s perception of the benefits of plant-based diets, focusing on environmental impact, health, and animal welfare. The research employs a survey-based approach using a representative sample of 715 French individuals. The methodology includes assessing the average knowledge about the relative merits of plant-based diets and exploring the heterogeneity of views across the population. The study aims to identify socio-economic groups with significantly different perspectives on the externalities of diets. The approach includes questions on the environmental impact (GHG emissions, land use), health impact (overall mortality), and animal welfare (number of killed animals, rearing conditions, and intensive farming). The survey also incorporates questions to gauge the participants’ level of confidence in their answers and their willingness to pay for information about the impacts of meat consumption. The study uses principal component analysis (PCA) to analyze the reported GHG emissions and land use, and assesses the perceived benefits of plant-based diets in comparison to animal-based diets. The study design also includes an indicator, called the Intensive Farming Underestimation Score (IFUS) to determine how people view the intensity of animal farming in France.
Key Findings & Statistics
- A global shift toward plant-based diets could significantly mitigate the negative impact of the food system on the environment, health, and animal welfare.
- Agriculture currently accounts for about 40% of global land use, up to 30% of global greenhouse gas emissions, and 70% of freshwater consumption.
- Plant-based diets have been shown to require less land, emit fewer GHG emissions, and necessitate less water than animal-based diets.
- The study used a representative sample of the French population (N=715).
- Consumers tend to have, on average, a good knowledge of the GHG impact of diets.
- Flexitarian (96.9%), vegetarian (96.5%) and vegan diets (96.2%) emit fewer GHG than the benchmark diet (75g meat).
- About 76.5% of consumers consider that the diet rich in meat emits more GHG compared to the benchmark diet.
- About 9 out of 10 respondents correctly report that the flexitarian, vegetarian and vegan diets use less land than the benchmark diet (resp. 93.4%, 86.2%, 87.1%).
- About 75.1% of the respondents report that the rich-in-meat diet needs more land than the benchmark diet.
- The median respondent also reports 9 correct orderings out of 10 pairwise comparisons.
- In the study, two groups of individuals were observed in the population: those who have positive views on plant-based diets on all dimensions, and those who have more negative views on all dimensions.
- The scientific work further shows that a large-scale shift towards plant-based diets would also bring sizable co-benefits for human health.
- Recent projections estimate that about 18 million deaths could be avoided in 2030 worldwide with the adoption of plant-based diets, saving USD 1.2-1.3 trillion in healthcare-related costs.
- More than 70 billion terrestrial animals are farmed and killed each year for food production, including 69 billion chickens and 1.5 billion pigs (FAO).
- In the US, the Sentience Institute estimates that about 99% of the farmed animals live on factory farms.
- The study found that the average knowledge of the French population on the relative merits of plant-based diets on the environment, health, and animal welfare varies.
- The environmental benefits of the vegan diet are underestimated compared to the vegetarian diet.
- People tend to have a good perception of the healthiness of foods.
- Six out of ten respondents report that the flexitarian diet is expected to decrease overall mortality (60.4%), and half of the respondents expect plant-based diets to do so (45.7% for vegetarianism, 49.8% for veganism).
- 73% of the respondents underestimate the number of terrestrial animals slaughtered daily for the food system.
- Only 11% of the respondents report that between 2 and 4 million animals are killed daily.
- About 16% of the participants overestimate this number (more than 4 million animals slaughtered daily).
- 63% of the respondents report less than 29% outdoor access for egg-laying hens, while only 23% report about 39% (5 points above the correct answer).
- The median respondent believes that 20% of pigs have outdoor access.
- Respondents believe on average that half of the hens (54.1%) or broilers (56%) are raised in farms with less than 20,000 animals on the farm, while only 22% of the hens and 31% of the broilers do so.
- Only 46.9% of the consumers correctly report that the vegetarian diet emits more GHG than the vegan diet.
- Only 42.2% of the consumers correctly report that the vegetarian diet necessitates more land than the vegan diet.
Other Important Findings
- The study reveals that French people have good knowledge of the environmental benefits of plant-based diets, specifically in terms of GHG emissions and land use.
- The environmental benefits of a vegan diet are underestimated compared to a vegetarian diet.
- People tend to systematically underestimate the overall health benefits of plant-based diets, as predicted by scientific studies.
- A large portion of the French population underestimates the negative impact of the current diet on farmed animals.
- Significant correlations were found between the perception of benefits across environmental, health, and animal welfare dimensions.
- Individuals with positive views on plant-based diets across all dimensions were identified, as well as those with more negative views.
- Individuals who consume more animal-based products tend to hold more negative views on plant-based diets and are less inclined to seek information about their impacts.
- The study found that the environmental benefits of plant-based diets might have limited potential in the long run, as people already report a good knowledge of the topic.
- The study also reveals that people tend to significantly underestimate the health benefits of plant-based diets and considerably underestimate the level of intensive farming.
Limitations Noted in the Document
- The study acknowledges that the level of real knowledge might be underestimated, as some people might hide information for self-serving reasons.
- The study is exploratory in nature and was not pre-registered.
- The study notes that official data on farm practices do not always exist or are not made public by authorities.
- The questions are de facto framed differently across topics.
- The definition of correct / incorrect answers is sensitive to the thresholds we consider.
- The study is based on self-reported data, which may be subject to biases.
- The study does not detect any specific socio-demographic profile for people who hold negative views about plant-based diets, except that, as expected, they tend to eat more animal-based products.
Conclusion
The study’s primary finding is that, while the French population generally understands the environmental advantages of plant-based diets, there is a significant underestimation of the health and animal welfare benefits associated with them. This indicates that informational campaigns regarding the environmental benefits might have limited effectiveness because the general public already has a good grasp of this aspect. “We find indeed that people who negatively perceive plant-based diets are more likely to consume animal-based products and are less willing to get informed on the impacts of animal-based diets,” indicating the potential for motivated reasoning among consumers. “Our results suggest that strategies aiming to inform consumers about the environmental benefits of plant-based diets might have a limited impact: on average, consumers have relatively good knowledge of the environmental question but we still observe high levels of meat consumption in our society,” Strategies that aim to inform consumers about the health or animal welfare benefits of plant-based diets might be more powerful. The study points out a gap in understanding, particularly regarding the impact on health and animal welfare. “We observe that people tend to significantly underestimate the health benefits of plant-based diets and considerably underestimate the level of intensive farming,” indicating that future campaigns could be more effective by focusing on these underexplored dimensions. Furthermore, the study observes a correlation between attitudes and behaviors, noting that “respondents with more negative views are more likely to eat animal-based products and are less willing to get informed on the impact of animal-based diets.” This suggests a need for more targeted messaging that addresses the factors driving these negative perceptions. The conclusion emphasizes the need to tailor future interventions to inform consumers about the health and animal welfare benefits of plant-based diets to have a more impactful effect on consumer behavior and promote the adoption of more sustainable eating habits.