Abstract
Objective: Low-carbohydrate diets and their combination with high-protein diets have been gaining widespread popularity to control weight. In addition to weight loss, they may have favorable short-term effects on the risk factors of cardiovascular disease (CVD). Our objective was to elucidate their long-term effects on mortality and CVD incidence. Data sources: MEDLINE, EMBASE, ISI Web of Science, Cochrane Library, and ClinicalTrials.gov for relevant articles published as of September 2012. Cohort studies of at least one year’s follow-up period were included. Review methods: Identified articles were systematically reviewed and those with pertinent data were selected for meta-analysis. Pooled risk ratios (RRs) with 95% confidence intervals (CIs) for all-cause mortality, CVD mortality and CVD incidence were calculated using the random-effects model with inverse-variance weighting. Results: We included 17 studies for a systematic review, followed by a meta-analysis using pertinent data. Of the 272,216 people in 4 cohort studies using the low-carbohydrate score, 15,981 (5.9%) cases of death from all-cause were reported. The risk of all-cause mortality among those with high low-carbohydrate score was significantly elevated: the pooled RR (95% CI) was 1.31 (1.07-1.59). A total of 3,214 (1.3%) cases of CVD death among 249,272 subjects in 3 cohort studies and 5,081 (2.3%) incident CVD cases among 220,691 people in different 4 cohort studies were reported. The risks of CVD mortality and incidence were not statistically increased: the pooled RRs (95% CIs) were 1.10 (0.98–1.24) and 0.98 (0.78–1.24), respectively. Analyses using low-carbohydrate/high-protein score yielded similar results. Conclusion: Low-carbohydrate diets were associated with a significantly higher risk of all-cause mortality and they were not significantly associated with a risk of CVD mortality and incidence. However, this analysis is based on limited observational studies and large-scale trials on the complex interactions between low-carbohydrate diets and long-term outcomes are needed.
Generated Summary
This study conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis of observational studies to elucidate the long-term effects of low-carbohydrate diets on mortality and cardiovascular disease (CVD) incidence. The research employed a random-effects model with inverse-variance weighting to calculate pooled risk ratios (RRs) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) for all-cause mortality, CVD mortality, and CVD incidence. The study included articles published up to September 2012, focusing on cohort studies with at least one year of follow-up. The primary objective was to assess the long-term effects of low-carbohydrate diets, which have gained popularity for weight control and may affect CVD risk factors.
Key Findings & Statistics
- The study included 17 studies for systematic review, with a meta-analysis of pertinent data.
- Among 272,216 people in 4 cohort studies using the low-carbohydrate score, 15,981 (5.9%) cases of death from all-cause were reported.
- The pooled RR (95% CI) for all-cause mortality among those with a high low-carbohydrate score was 1.31 (1.07-1.59).
- A total of 3,214 (1.3%) cases of CVD death were reported among 249,272 subjects in 3 cohort studies.
- 5,081 (2.3%) incident CVD cases were reported among 220,691 people in 4 cohort studies.
- The pooled RRs (95% CIs) for CVD mortality and incidence were not statistically increased, with values of 1.10 (0.98-1.24) and 0.98 (0.78-1.24), respectively.
- Analysis using low-carbohydrate/high-protein score yielded similar results.
- A total of 492 articles were initially identified.
- 18 articles were assessed for eligibility.
- 17 cohort studies were included in the systematic review and meta-analysis.
- The population sample size ranged from 647 to 129,716 across the studies.
- In the computation of the low-carbohydrate diet score, percentages of energy from protein and carbohydrate were divided into deciles.
- The risk of all-cause mortality was significantly elevated: the pooled RR (95% CI) was 1.31 (1.07-1.59); p = 0.007; I² = 53% (p = 0.09).
- Analysis using the LC/HP score yielded a similar significant increase in the risk of all-cause mortality: RR 1.30 (1.01-1.68); p=0.04; I² = 65% (p=0.04).
- A dose-response was observed in 2 analyses.
- The pooled RRs of the studies conducted in Europe and the United States (RR 1.42 [1.18-1.72] vs 1.12 [1.01-1.24]) were both significantly elevated.
- The RRs of CVD mortality and incidence were not statistically significant: RR 1.10 (0.98-1.24); p = 0.12; I² = 0% (p = 0.41), RR 0.98 (0.78–1.24); p = 0.87; I² = 53% (p = 0.09), respectively.
Other Important Findings
- The study found that low-carbohydrate diets were associated with a significantly higher risk of all-cause mortality.
- Low-carbohydrate diets were not significantly associated with a risk of CVD mortality and incidence.
- Analyses using the low-carbohydrate/high-protein score yielded similar results.
- The study suggests that low-carbohydrate diets might not be protective or harmful in terms of CVD mortality and incidence.
- The findings support the hypothesis that the short-term benefits of low-carbohydrate diets for weight loss are potentially irrelevant.
- Low-carbohydrate diets tend to result in reduced intake of fiber and fruits, and increased intake of protein from animal sources, cholesterol and saturated fat, all of which are risk factors for mortality and CVD.
- The study notes that the increment in all-cause mortality might have been partly attributable to the increased risks for CVD mortality and morbidity.
Limitations Noted in the Document
- The study acknowledges limitations inherent in observational studies, including the potential for publication bias and residual confounding.
- The number of studies on CVD mortality risk may not have been sufficient for robust statistical power.
- The representativeness of the cohorts may be limited, as healthcare professionals were a significant part of the study populations in some cases.
- The causal relationships may not be definitively established due to potential confounding factors and biases that may not have been fully accounted for.
- The study notes that the results may not be generalizable to diabetic patients or other populations.
- The observational nature of the studies makes it difficult to ascertain causality.
- The study acknowledges the possibility of publication bias and residual confounding.
- It is difficult to distinguish the effects of individual nutritional components.
Conclusion
The meta-analysis indicated that low-carbohydrate diets were associated with a significantly higher risk of all-cause mortality. The findings underscore the need for further investigation into the long-term health effects of low-carbohydrate diets. The study found no significant association between low-carbohydrate diets and CVD mortality or incidence. The research highlights that the short-term benefits of low-carbohydrate diets for weight loss may be unrelated to long-term outcomes. Given the fact that low-carbohydrate diets are likely unsafe and that calorie restriction has been demonstrated to be effective in weight loss regardless of nutritional composition, it would be prudent not to recommend low-carbohydrate diets for the time being. Further detailed studies to evaluate the effect of protein source are urgently needed. The study’s findings support the hypothesis that the short-term benefits of low-carbohydrate diets for weight loss are potentially irrelevant. The study underscores the need for large-scale trials to examine the complex interplay between low-carbohydrate diets and long-term health outcomes, emphasizing the importance of considering the broader implications of dietary choices beyond weight loss. The study points to the need for further investigation of long-term health effects and also highlights the importance of understanding the interaction between low-carbohydrate diets and long-term health outcomes.
IFFS Team Summary
- meta-analysis of 17 different studies including 272 000 subjects
- Those with a high low-carbohydrate score had ~31% increased all cause mortality
- Cardiovascular mortality was equivocal between groups
- could this be due to deaths that were undifferentiated, i.e. sudden death, that were likely cardiovascular but not diagnosed clinically
- could this be due to deaths that were undifferentiated, i.e. sudden death, that were likely cardiovascular but not diagnosed clinically
- Involved percentile type studies, dividing people by low carb and low carb/high protein scores