Abstract
On the face of it, many developing countries, even least developed ones, seem to be doing just fine in terms of agricultural production and trade expansion. This paper cannot answer the question whether the present multilateral rules framework strengthens or imperils resource-poor countries and farmers. Instead, it describes a ‘reform programme’ which is far from being completed, and it shows where the ‘development promises’ of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) and the World Trade Organization (WTO) remain unfulfilled. Based on the experiences with the Uruguay Round, it argues that even the completion of the Doha Development Round is likely to fail to address some specific concerns of net food-importing developing countries (NFIDC) and resource-poor farmers. A number of additional specific commitments by developed and emerging economies are required to fulfil the promise “to establish a fair and market-oriented agricultural trading system”.
Generated Summary
This paper examines the impact of the World Trade Organization (WTO) on developing countries, particularly in the context of agricultural trade. It analyzes the historical context of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) and the WTO, focusing on the ‘development promise’ made at the inception of GATT and how it has remained unfulfilled, especially in agriculture. The study utilizes a ‘reform programme’ perspective to evaluate the progress and shortcomings in agricultural trade liberalization, considering the three pillars of the Agreement on Agriculture (AoA). The methodology involves a review of existing literature, data analysis of trade patterns, and an assessment of the Doha Development Agenda (DDA). The scope includes an examination of trade-distorting policies, subsidy disparities, and the implications for developing countries, particularly the net food-importing developing countries (NFIDC) and resource-poor farmers. The paper aims to highlight the challenges faced by developing countries in the current multilateral rules framework and suggests potential solutions for a more equitable development outcome, considering the growing differences between developing countries and the need for a Doha Final Act.
Key Findings & Statistics
- The Uruguay Round aimed to achieve agricultural trade liberalization, including tariffication and limits on export subsidies and domestic support.
- Developed countries increased Green Box expenditures, reaching on average 14.2% of the value of production. The four developing countries covered also increased Green Box support, which rose on average to 7% of the value of their production.
- In absolute terms, the total support of all 10 countries increased between 2001 and 2012, growing more rapidly in the four developing countries (China, Brazil, India, and Indonesia), where the starting base was much lower.
- When compared to the value of production, support in developed countries was stable while in developing countries the proportion increased, although at the end of the period developed countries’ support was still proportionately higher, at, on average, 19.3% of the value of production, whereas in these developing countries it was on average 12.4%.
- The Cairns Group paper underlines that in absolute terms, the total support of all 10 increased between 2001 and 2012, growing more rapidly in the four developing countries (China, Brazil, India, and Indonesia) where the starting base was much lower.
- The share of industrial goods in merchandise trade rose from 38% to 77% between 1970 and 1996.
- By 2024, real prices may have declined from their 2014 levels, but will remain above their pre-2007 levels.
- Foreign trade distortions, primarily in the form of state-provided export incentives, are responsible for cutting LDC exports by an average of 5.5% per annum.
Other Important Findings
- The paper highlights that despite the progress made, agricultural trade remains ‘special’ under the current rules framework, with tariffication and modest reductions in protection and subsidization.
- The study identifies an increasing number of trade-distorting practices in emerging economies, even with WTO limits, with some of these new support policies notified under the ‘Developing Country Green Box’, but may be damaging for developing countries without sufficient financial resources.
- The continuation of the ‘reform programme’ promised in Article 20 of the Agreement on Agriculture (AoA) collapsed in 2008 with the Doha Development Agenda (DDA), leaving the ‘haves’ with spending ceilings way above those of the (mostly) developing country ‘have nots’.
- Desta argues that the ‘efficiency model’ role of international trade, as advocated by Malthus, Smith, Ricardo, Samuelson, Dunoff and Hudec, simply cannot work on an uneven playing field.
- The research points out that the ‘development promise’ made right at the inception of the GATT in 1947, and consistently repeated especially for agriculture, has remained unfulfilled.
- The lack of ambitious market access commitments will neither reduce consumer prices nor improve food security by facilitating trade flows.
- The re-instrumentation of support, and the decline in world market prices after 1995, brought about a huge ‘subsidy overhang’: most developed countries have shifted much of their farm support from market and price interventions to publicly-funded government programmes and measures with “no, or at most minimal, trade-distorting effects or effects on production”.
- Desta acknowledges the progress GATT and WTO have brought about for industrial goods whose share in merchandise trade rose from 38 % to 77 % in the period from 1970 to 1996.
- The food crisis of 2007-08 and the ensuing financial crisis exposed some of the weaknesses of the multilateral trading system.
- The paper points out that the absence of new disciplines in export restrictions and export competition, especially by way of food aid, are the most blatant threats to food security.
Limitations Noted in the Document
- The paper acknowledges that the causal link between the AoA and the extent and the impact of positive and negative developments is debatable.
- The study does not provide solutions for developing countries in agricultural trade, but rather a framework of analysis for the development challenges in the agricultural context.
- There is a risk that the increasing recourse to Article 6.2, especially by large countries, is unlikely to reduce trade distortions.
- The research acknowledges that some of the views expressed are based on the historical and theoretical analysis.
Conclusion
The paper concludes that the Doha Development Agenda (DDA) with its export-biased and unilinear duty and subsidy reduction approach fails to provide these countries and their farmers with the tools they need when facing their better-supported competitors both at home and on regional and world markets. The paper suggests a way forward with a to-do list for a more equitable development outcome, which include retaining ample policy space for at least the temporary protection of fragile agricultural producers. Furthermore, an increase in domestic support flexibility for developing countries may be necessary. The paper also suggests the need to prevent ‘Basmati Wars’, and new production risk insurance schemes may require a special provision in the Green Box, and under the relevant export competition disciplines. Moreover, the paper highlights that the absence of new disciplines in export restrictions and export competition, especially by way of food aid, are the most blatant threats to food security, and that additional food aid disciplines are needed which not only prevent ‘commercial displacement’ but also protect local producers. Finally, the study recommends mandatory and quantified Aid for Trade, a specific part of which should then be earmarked for food crop production in NFIDC, a formal commitment not to decrease food aid when food prices on the world market increase, and securing non-reciprocal trade preferences for countries whose food security depends on their exports. As stated by the author: “For Desta, the ‘efficiency model’ role of international trade, as advocated by Malthus, Smith, Ricardo, Samuelson, Dunoff and Hudec, simply cannot work on an uneven playing field.” The paper’s insights underscore the importance of addressing these issues to ensure that the WTO’s agricultural trade framework supports equitable development and food security for all, particularly for the most vulnerable nations.