Abstract
Food trade is generally perceived to increase the availability and diversity of foods available to consumers, but there is little empirical evidence on its implications for human health. Here we show that a substantial proportion of dietary risks and diet-related mortality worldwide is attributable to international food trade and that whether the contributions of food trade are positive or negative depends on the types of food traded. Using bilateral trade data for 2019 and food-specific risk-disease relationships, we estimate that imports of fruits, vegetables, legumes and nuts improved dietary risks in the importing countries and were associated with a reduction in mortality from non-communicable diseases of −1.4 million deaths globally. By contrast, imports of red meat aggravated dietary risks in the importing countries and were associated with an increase of ~150,000 deaths. The magnitude of our findings suggests that considering impacts on dietary risks will become an important aspect of health-sensitive trade and agriculture policies, and of policy responses to disruptions in food chains.
Generated Summary
This research article investigates the impact of international food trade on dietary risks and diet-related mortality at global, regional, and national levels. The study employs a quantitative approach, analyzing bilateral trade data from 2019 and linking it to food-specific risk-disease relationships. The primary methodology involves assessing the contributions of food trade to dietary risks, including the consumption of fruits, vegetables, legumes, nuts, and red meat, and their associated effects on mortality. The analysis aims to determine whether the trade’s effects are positive or negative depending on the types of food traded, and to identify the countries of origin for these foods. The study’s scope encompasses a global perspective, with regional and national-level analyses to understand the varying impacts of food trade across different areas. It seeks to provide insights for health-sensitive trade and agricultural policies and to inform responses to disruptions in food chains.
Key Findings & Statistics
- Global Mortality Reduction: International food trade associated with a net reduction in mortality from non-communicable diseases of -1.4 million deaths globally.
- Mortality Increase from Red Meat: Imports of red meat aggravated dietary risks and were associated with an increase of approximately 150,000 deaths.
- Impact of Fruit, Vegetable, Nut and Legume Imports: Imports of fruits, vegetables, legumes, and nuts improved dietary risks in the importing countries.
- Mortality Reduction from Fruits, Vegetables, Nuts and Legumes: Trade-related contributions to fruit intake were responsible for the largest reductions in mortality (-597,000), followed by vegetables (-380,000), nuts (-300,000) and legumes (-98,000).
- Impact on Coronary Heart Disease, Stroke, and Cancer: About half of the avoided deaths (53%) were from coronary heart disease, and a quarter each from stroke (25%) and cancer (23%).
- European Benefit: Over half of the total reductions in diet-related mortality were associated with food imports to Europe (-675,000; 55%).
- American Benefit: Imports to the Americas associated with a reduction of (-209,000;17%)
- Asian Benefit: Imports to Asia associated with a reduction of (-301,000; 25%)
- African Benefit: Imports to Africa associated with a reduction of (-33,000; 3%)
- Oceania Benefit: Imports to Oceania associated with a reduction of (-7,000;1%)
- Leading Beneficiaries (Country Level): The United States (-140,000), Russia (-134,000), Germany (-107,000), China (-89,000), and the United Kingdom (-61,000) had the greatest health benefits.
- Papua New Guinea: The only country exhibiting a net increase in diet-related mortality from trade was Papua New Guinea (+4 deaths).
- China: China (-117,000) had the greatest health benefits, driven by vegetables and nuts,
- United States: The United States (-102,000) benefited from nuts and legumes.
- Brazil and Spain: Brazil (-92,000) and Spain (-86,000) had benefits from vegetables and fruits.
- Germany and Denmark: Germany (+10,000) and Denmark (+7,000) had the highest exports of red meat, leading to mortality increases.
- Ukraine: Ukrainian exports contributed to a net reduction in mortality in importing countries of 12,600 deaths.
- Russia: Russia is one of the main beneficiaries of importing health-promoting foods, associated with 134,000 less deaths.
Other Important Findings
- About a quarter of all food produced for human consumption is internationally traded.
- Food trade is generally perceived to increase the supply, access, and diversity of food available to consumers.
- The trade in foods makes substantial contributions to the magnitude and distribution of dietary risks worldwide.
- Europe was the largest net beneficiary of trade in dietary risks.
- The Americas were the largest net contributor to dietary risks.
- Africa exported more dietary risks than it imported.
- The study found that the embodied health impacts affect the importing country while the environmental and social impacts affect the exporting one.
- The study highlights the importance of considering the role food trade plays in dietary health irrespective of any particular policy measure.
- The study’s methodology is less time and context dependent than existing regression analyses and can be flexibly applied in future research, including in longitudinal studies of trade and analyses of past and future trade agreements.
Limitations Noted in the Document
- The analysis covered major dietary risks but did not analyze the impacts food trade can have on other aspects important for health, such as overweight and obesity.
- Process-based analyses of these and further health aspects related to trade are an important avenue for future research.
- The study is subject to caveats that apply to comparative risk assessments and nutritional epidemiology.
- The health analysis is based on the assumption that the risk-disease relationships we used to link changes in dietary risks to mortality describe causal associations.
- Residual confounding with unaccounted risk factors cannot be ruled out entirely in epidemiological studies.
Conclusion
The study’s findings underscore the substantial contribution of international food trade to global dietary risks and mortality, with both positive and negative implications. The research highlights that food trade is crucial, leading to a net reduction in mortality, especially through the import of fruits, vegetables, legumes, and nuts, particularly in Europe, the Americas, and Asia. However, the negative impacts associated with red meat imports, especially from European and Latin American countries, underscore the complexity of this relationship. The study suggests that policy interventions, such as reducing tariffs on health-promoting foods and appropriate agricultural policies in exporting countries, are crucial for safeguarding the health benefits of trade. The case of the Russian invasion of Ukraine exemplifies how disruptions in food trade can have significant health implications, emphasizing the need for policies that mitigate the negative impacts and promote a sustainable and healthy food system. The study concludes that safeguarding the trade in health-promoting foods and limiting those of unhealthy ones will be important aspects of trade and agricultural policies. This research enhances the current literature by directly linking food trade to final health outcomes, providing country-level analyses, and offering a flexible method for future research and policy applications.