Abstract
Objective: To summarize the association between vegetarian versus non-vegetarian diet on mortality due to ischemic heart disease, cerebrovascular disease, or all-cause mortality. Methods: We searched PubMed, Cochrane databases, and Clinical Trials.Gov from the inception of the databases to October 2019 with no language restriction. Randomized controlled trials or prospective observational studies comparing the association between vegetarian versus non-vegetarian diets among adults and reporting major adverse cardiovascular outcomes were selected. We used Paule-Mandel estimator for tau2 with Hartung-Knapp adjustment for random effects model to estimate risk ratio [RR] with 95% confidence interval [CI]. The primary outcome of interest was all-cause mortality. The secondary outcome was ischemic heart disease mortality. Results: Eight observational studies (n = 131,869) were included in the analysis. Over a weighted mean follow-up of 10.68 years, very low certainty of evidence concluded that a vegetarian diet compared with a non-vegetarian diet was associated with similar risk of all-cause (RR: 0.84, 95% CI: 0.65-1.07, 12: 97%) or cerebrovascular mortality (RR: 0.84, 95% CI: 0.63-1.14, 2: 90%), but was associated with a reduced risk of ischemic heart disease mortality (RR: 0.70, 95% CI: 0.55-0.89, 12: 82%). Conclusion: A vegetarian diet, compared with a non-vegetarian diet, was associated with a reduced risk of ischemic heart disease mortality, whereas it had no effect on all-cause and cerebrovascular mortality. However, the results are to be considered with caution considering the low certainty of evidence. Despite recent studies supporting no restriction on animal protein intake gaining wide media attention and public traction, consideration for vegetarianism amongst those with risk factors for coronary artery disease should be contemplated.
Generated Summary
This meta-analysis, published in the American Journal of Preventive Cardiology, investigates the effects of vegetarian diets on mortality related to ischemic heart disease (IHD), cerebrovascular disease, and all-cause mortality. The study design involved a search of databases including PubMed and Cochrane, from their inception to October 2019, without language restrictions. The researchers selected randomized controlled trials or prospective observational studies that compared vegetarian and non-vegetarian diets among adults and reported major cardiovascular outcomes. The Paule-Mandel estimator was used to calculate risk ratios with 95% confidence intervals, and the primary outcome was all-cause mortality. Eight observational studies were included in the analysis, covering a weighted mean follow-up period of 10.68 years. The study aimed to provide updated evidence on the potential mortality benefits of vegetarian diets and its association with cardiovascular health, particularly in relation to IHD and cerebrovascular disease.
Key Findings & Statistics
- The analysis included eight observational studies (n = 131,869).
- The weighted mean follow-up period was 10.68 years.
- A vegetarian diet was associated with a similar risk of all-cause mortality compared with a non-vegetarian diet (RR: 0.84, 95% CI: 0.65-1.07, I²: 97%).
- Outlier analysis identified the study by Berkel et al. (1965) as an outlier.
- After excluding the outlier, the relative risk of all-cause mortality with a vegetarian diet compared with a non-vegetarian diet remained similar (RR: 0.91, 95% CI: 0.79-1.05), and the I² reduced to 88%.
- A vegetarian diet was associated with a significantly reduced risk of mortality due to IHD compared with a non-vegetarian diet (RR: 0.70, 95% CI: 0.55-0.89, I²: 82%).
- Outlier analysis identified studies by Berkel et al. (1965) and Health Food Shoppers (1995) as outliers.
- After excluding these studies, the relative risk of mortality due to IHD with a vegetarian diet compared with a non-vegetarian diet remained lower (RR: 0.70, 95% CI: 0.61-0.80), and the I² reduced to 2%.
- A vegetarian diet was associated with a similar risk of mortality due to cerebrovascular disease compared with a non-vegetarian diet (RR: 0.84, 95% CI: 0.63-1.14, I²: 90%).
- Outlier analysis identified the study by Berkel et al. (1965) as an outlier.
- After excluding the outlier, the relative risk of mortality due to cerebrovascular disease with a vegetarian diet compared with a non-vegetarian diet remained similar (RR: 0.93, 95% CI: 0.74-1.18), and the I² reduced to 35%.
Other Important Findings
- The study found a 30% reduction in mortality due to IHD among those following a vegetarian diet.
- No reduction was observed in mortality due to cerebrovascular disease or all-cause mortality.
- The study highlighted that the results should be considered cautiously due to the low certainty of evidence.
- The study noted that previous meta-analyses had limitations, such as focusing on red meat, including pescatarian/semi-vegetarian diets, or failing to report IHD or cerebrovascular mortality.
- The study suggests that a vegetarian diet, compared with a non-vegetarian diet, may reduce the risk of ischemic heart disease mortality.
Limitations Noted in the Document
- The study’s conclusions are limited by the nature of the cohort studies used, which relied on questionnaires and subjective recall, lacking clear definitions of diets in some studies.
- Compliance with the specified diet could not be fully reported due to the observational nature of the studies.
- The non-randomized nature of the studies and the varied use of adjustments limited the reduction of confounding bias.
- The generalizability of the results is mainly limited by geographic distribution and diet profiles.
- The study acknowledges high heterogeneity in the all-cause mortality pooled estimate, which requires cautious interpretation.
- No randomized clinical trials met the search criteria, and the authors note the challenges in conducting such trials.
- The study did not differentiate between vegan/pesco or semi-vegetarian diets, and the inclusion of studies was limited to those with less than 5% of these diet groups.
Conclusion
The meta-analysis underscores that a vegetarian diet may offer benefits in reducing the risk of ischemic heart disease mortality, while it shows no significant impact on cerebrovascular disease or all-cause mortality. The findings emphasize the need for caution due to the low certainty of evidence and highlight the importance of future randomized clinical trials to validate these findings. The potential for a vegetarian diet to mitigate mortality and morbidity from IHD warrants further investigation. The reduced risk of IHD mortality, observed in the study, may be linked to the reduction in established risk factors for IHD. The current meta-analysis supports recommendations from major societies like the American Heart Association and the American Cancer Society, particularly for those at risk of coronary artery disease. Further research is needed to determine the role of vegetarian diets in specific subgroups, such as those with obesity, heart disease, or high blood pressure. The findings also indicate that a vegetarian diet may reduce the risk of ischemic heart disease mortality. The study also highlights that the reduction in mortality due to IHD observed in vegetarians may be related to a decrease in the risk factors associated with the disease. It also indicates that a vegetarian diet may not have any effect on the risk of death from cerebrovascular disease or all causes. The authors also suggest that the findings are limited by the reliance on observational data and the lack of consistent definitions of vegetarian diets across studies.