Abstract
This article shows how China’s rise has radically altered the politics of one of the most prominent and controversial issues in the global trading system: agriculture subsidies. Agriculture subsidies depress global prices and undermine the competitiveness and livelihoods of poor farmers, and therefore have been long seen as a symbol of the injustice of the trading system. The issue has traditionally been understood in North-South terms, with developed countries seen as the perpetrators of harm and developing countries as innocent victims. In this article, however, I challenge this prevailing conception of the agricultural subsidies issue, arguing that it is now out of date and no longer corresponds with the emerging reality. A momentous but underappreciated change has taken place, largely beneath the radar of IPE scholarship: China has emerged as the world’s largest subsidizer, profoundly transforming the global politics of agricultural subsidies. From a North-South battle, WTO negotiations on agricultural subsidies are now primarily centered on a conflict between the US and China. While reducing subsidies remains a pressing concern for developing countries, efforts to negotiate new and strengthened disciplines at the WTO have been thwarted by an impasse between the two dominant powers.
Generated Summary
This journal article analyzes the impact of China’s rise on the global politics of agricultural subsidies at the World Trade Organization (WTO). It argues that China’s emergence as a major agricultural subsidizer has transformed the dynamics of contestation in global trade governance, shifting the focus from a North-South battle to a conflict primarily between the US and China. The study uses field research conducted at the WTO in Geneva and other locations. The core methodology involves an in-depth examination of the positions and interests of the US and China, the implications of their conflict for developing countries, and the role of agricultural subsidies in the broader context of global trade governance.
Key Findings & Statistics
- China’s total support to agriculture, at 2.4% of GDP, is now four times higher than the OECD average (OECD, 2017).
- China provided an estimated $212 billion in farm subsidies in 2016, significantly more than the EU ($100 billion), US ($33 billion), or any other country (OECD, 2017).
- China’s support to agricultural producers represented 15% of gross farm receipts in 2014-16, with 74% provided via the most trade distorting forms of support (Figure 3).
- Support to farmers in the US constituted 9% of gross farm receipts, with 33% provided in the most trade distorting forms of support.
- China now accounts for more than half of the world’s support for rice and more than three-quarters of support for corn (Greenville, 2017).
- China has amassed 60% of the world’s cotton supplies, over 50% of its corn, 40% of wheat and 21% of soybeans (Rabobank, 2016).
- In China, state support now represents a significant portion of revenue for many commodities: subsidies constitute 38% of gross farm receipts for wheat, 29% for corn, 32% for rice, 49% for sugar, and 44% for cotton.
- China’s agricultural production has grown dramatically: its share of global production has more than doubled, from 18% in 1995–97 to 43% in 2014-16 (Figure 4).
- US agricultural exports to China peaked in 2012 at $26 billion, but in subsequent years fell by over 25% (USDA, 2016a).
- The US wheat industry, for instance, maintains that China’s subsidies cost world wheat exporters $3 billion in lost revenue annually, with American farmers specifically losing over $650 million.
- China’s cotton subsidies were estimated at $5.3 billion in 2015-16 (compared to $1.1 billion for the US) (ICAC, 2016b). China accounts for nearly three-quarters of the $7.2 billion in cotton subsidies provided worldwide (Figure 5).
- In China, cotton subsidies constitute more than 40% of gross farm receipts, compared to less than 20% in the US (Greenville, 2017).
Other Important Findings
- The article highlights how China’s rise has radically altered the politics of agricultural subsidies at the WTO.
- China has emerged as the world’s largest subsidizer of agriculture.
- WTO negotiations on agricultural subsidies are now primarily centered on a conflict between the US and China.
- Efforts to negotiate new and strengthened disciplines at the WTO have been thwarted by an impasse between the two dominant powers.
- China is now the world’s largest agricultural producer and exporter.
- China’s agricultural subsidies are concentrated in the most trade-distorting forms of support.
- China’s subsidies artificially boost its agricultural production, resulting in reduced demand for imports and lower global prices, to the detriment of agricultural producers and exporters around the world.
- The US has turned the tables and gone on the offensive against China’s subsidies in both WTO negotiations and dispute settlement.
- China’s stance is that, as a developing country, it is entitled to special and differential treatment (SDT) and should not be required to make further concessions.
- The US and China are in a fundamental conflict that has barred any progress on disciplining agricultural domestic support.
- Developing countries are largely sidelined in the post-Doha negotiations on agricultural subsidies.
- The US-China conflict dominates the negotiations, and other developing countries are hesitant to challenge China.
- Cotton subsidies serve as a striking illustration of the new politics of agricultural subsidies.
Limitations Noted in the Document
- The analysis is based on research conducted between 2007 and 2018, and the situation may have evolved since.
- The study focuses on the perspectives of the US and China and does not fully explore the internal dynamics of other countries.
- The article does not provide detailed analysis on the specifics of agricultural policies.
- The study acknowledges that the US and China’s focus on the issue is also a product of their larger economic and geopolitical rivalry, implying that other factors may influence the situation.
Conclusion
The central argument of the article is that China’s rise has fundamentally shifted the landscape of agricultural subsidies within the WTO. The conflict is now largely defined by the US and China, with developing countries finding their interests sidelined. The article emphasizes that the traditional view of agricultural subsidies as a North-South issue is outdated. The impact of China’s policies on global markets is significant, and it challenges the established order of the WTO. A key takeaway is that the US-China conflict has led to a standstill in negotiations, with the potential for serious implications for global trade. As one negotiator stated, “The US says ‘China, you tell us you only subsidize poor farmers, but if you look in aggregate, you see how important they are in distorting the market’. Then the argument from China is ‘we’re not exporting, you the US are exporting, so you are more dangerous for the C-4 and LDCs than me’” China’s stance that it is a developing country, and therefore exempt from further concessions, is a significant challenge. This view complicates the efforts to reduce subsidies and achieve fair trade. The article concludes by emphasizing the need to address the issue. While the US and China continue to argue about who is more virtuous, it is the developing countries who are suffering. “With the system’s two dominant powers at loggerheads, each blaming the other for the cotton problem, efforts to discipline cotton subsidies via the WTO have come to a standstill.” The article underlines the complex political dynamics at play, and it highlights the need for a multilateral approach to address the challenges of agricultural subsidies. The article underscores the importance of the US-China relationship. The issue of agricultural subsidies reflects the broader economic competition and geopolitical rivalry between the US and China. The impact of China’s rise is not limited to trade but also extends to the power dynamics within international institutions.